I’m pretty sure the correct drink to pair with Girl Scout Cookies is milk, but what do I know? A website just put together a guide of what wines you should pair with the 12 different types of Girl Scout Cookies, now that they’re on sale again.

One quick warning: The pairing list is pretty intense — they didn’t just pick generic wines you probably have around the house, they got specific and obscure.

Like, they recommend pairing Thin Mints with a good Brunello; Samoas with an aged Rioja; and Tagalongs with an Amarone. You can check out the full, intimidating list at Vivino.com.